Jesus Did Not Hate Religion, Nor Should We

religion:  1. The belief in a superhuman controlling power, especially in a personal God entitled to obedience and worship. 2. The expression of this in worship. 3. A particular system of faith and worship.

By now you have likely seen the video called “Why I Hate Religion, But Love Jesus.” If not, you can watch it here. It would probably be helpful if you would take a look at it before you read the rest of what I have written below.

The video features a young man named Jefferson Bethke “performing,” in something of a rap or hip-hop style, the text of a poem he wrote to contrast true Christian faith with “false religion.” So far it has been viewed nearly 9 million times on youtube. 176,000 people “like” the video while 22,000 people “dislike” it. If I had to be placed in one of those two categories, it would be (and I say this with some sadness) the latter.

The video is very well done, clearly a professional production with high quality sound and impressive graphics. I have worked in broadcasting, and I commend the producers of this piece for their attention to detail and their commitment to excellence. In fact, I think its quality as a video production, as in the case of most pop and rock music videos, has greatly increased its popularity. The same content, simply read or recited, minus the slick production values, would not likely have gone viral to the degree this piece has. (And once again, Marshall McLuhan’s dictum that “the medium is the message” proves uncannily and disturbingly accurate.)

Jefferson Bethke is, I believe, 21 years old. From all I can tell, he is a thoughtful young man and a committed Christian. I have read some of what he has written on Facebook and Twitter, and he seems remarkably grounded in his faith and admirably humble in response to his critics. He is also, in large part, wrong when he juxtaposes Jesus and religion.

Contrary to what Jefferson Bethke says, Jesus did not hate religion. Nor should we.

Jesus was a devout Jew. He observed Jewish holy days (such as Passover) and attended synagogue services. (One of His most important sermons was delivered in the synagogue in His hometown of Nazareth.) He was addressed as “rabbi” by people who probably had never seen Him before, leading many (including me) to assume that he wore some kind of distinctive attire, the first-century Jewish equivalent of a clerical collar. (Which, by the way, is precisely why I wear one.)

To assert, as Bethke does, that religion causes wars is tantamount to blaming the divorce rate on marriage or suggesting that politics is responsible for corruption among elected officials. In each of these cases, it is a distortion of the institution that has produced the undesirable effect. It is, in fact, the human practitioners and participants who have done such damage to marriage, politics, and yes, religion.

I agree with Jefferson Bethke’s basic premise. Jesus Christ died on the cross in order to make possible the restoration of relationship between a holy God and sinful humans. As a result of Jesus’ death and resurrection, God extends to wretched humanity an offer of mercy, grace, love, and forgiveness. And we are  required to do nothing but believe and accept in order to receive all that He offers.

I disagree, however, with his blanket condemnation of religion. In lumping into the generic category of religion every distasteful, even repugnant, characteristic of people who claim to be religious but show little evidence of an encounter with God, Bethke has thrown the baby out with the bath water. In fact, that is what I find so objectionable about this video.

Jefferson Bethke is apparently a devoted Christian with a discerning mind and a sensitive spirit. Unfortunately, many who watch this video will not exhibit those qualities. To the degree that this video makes people aware of the grace and forgiveness which Jesus offers, I applaud the effort. I fear, however, that it may exacerbate an unsettling trend in contemporary Christianity. That is, it may encourage people, young people especially, to abandon the institutional church altogether. It could increase the perception that true Christian faith is an individualized experience, a “Jesus and me” proposition that requires no involvement with or participation in an organized faith community of any sort. That would be an unfortunate consequence of a well-meaning and rightly-motivated endeavor.

Jesus did not hate religion. He condemned self-righteousness, hypocrisy, greed, pride, injustice, and oppression. So should we. Jesus criticized those who misused their religious authority and distorted the tenets of their faith in order to advance their own interests and increase their power. So should we. Jesus longed for His people, the Jews, to recognize in Him the fulfillment to which their religion pointed. But He never meant to encourage the abandonment of all structure and organization, which human social interaction requires in order to provide meaningful relationships and appropriate accountability.

Insofar as the church and organized religion have lost sight of the true purpose which they are to serve in God’s economy, they need to be renewed and reformed. Let’s pray for revival of true religion, but let’s not abandon the idea nor forsake the institution. Jesus didn’t.

8 thoughts on “Jesus Did Not Hate Religion, Nor Should We

  1. I want to offer a hearty and heartfelt “thank you!” to you for saying this! I could not agree more.

    As a pastor, I see and hear the comments by people intent on making “church” something of the past. They are totally on the band wagon with the “anti-religious” crowd who say “you don’t need church to worship God.” They fail to understand the importance of a religious community, a family, that builds strength through fellowship and accountability. All they can focus on is one’s individual perspective and the poor examples of what church should be.

    Christ died for the lost and lonely sinner. He spoke of leaving the 99 to find the one. But Jesus was not only concerned with the individual, for He spoke often of His church, the body of believers, the “called out ones” of whom He prayed, “Father, I pray they be one, as we are one.”

    Thanks, again.
    Psalm 57:2

  2. I am with Pastor Baker. Not meaning to shamelessly plug my own blog, but my first post was “I Love/Hate Religion”, pretty much for these reasons. My wife and I have discussed this video and came to pretty much the same conclusion as you.

    The reason for this comment: God has spoken through you, and I am going to use this post in my next young adult lesson (as well as the video with it).

    Blessings, brother!


  3. While I will agree that Mr. Bethke probably took his analogy a bit too far, I can’t disagree with the general premise. I don’t think that Jesus opposed religion in and of itself, but it’s very difficult to argue that the doctrinal differences within various denominations have frequently led to, or at least been the reason given, for multiple wars throughout human history. I pray that he is not really calling for the dissolution of the institutional church, because we are indeed called by Christ to gather together in worship. But we are called as the Church, the body of Christ, and not a particular religion. That’s akin to the Roman Catholic claim that they are “the church founded by Jesus Christ” or the Mormon claim that “there is no salvation outside the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints.”
    As for Jesus being called “rabbi” (or rabboni in Aramaic, both of which mean “teacher”), that is true, but there is no Biblical evidence that I have seen that would indicate He was dressed in anything other than the dress of the common man of the day. He was, after all, raised as the son of a carpenter.
    As for His being a devout Jew, that was necessary. Jesus had to be perfect under the Law in order to fulfill the Law, so that the Law could no longer condemn us in our sin.
    I do believe this: It’s not about a religion, it’s about a relationship. When Jesus sacrificed Himself for us, He tore the veil that lead to the Holy of Holies, allowing us direct access to the Father through Himself. If you don’t have a personal relationship with Christ, I think you’re missing out.

    • Excellent comments from all. Unfortunately, the fallen state of man requires the structure of religion. However I don’t think religion and denominational-ism is all negative. The varying worship styles and minor differences in doctrine provide a place where people can “fit”.

      That said, I don’t think you can call the Acts 2 picture of Christ followers a “religion” – although it quickly became one. It was a community of believers. Another thought, do you think there is religion in eternity?

      Last point: Wars are almost ALWAYS over land, money, influence, etc – ultimately power. Religion has almost exclusively been used as an excuse to service the aspirations of a person or group. Religion is an easy target.

  4. I’ve been saying this for years in sound bytes, but you brought together the strands well. There’s the biblical critique of empty religious service, such as Isaiah 58 criticizing fasting without justice. But the solution is not justice without the organized worship God also prescribed in order to nurture fidelity.

    There’s a baby in that bathwater people!

  5. I agree that it is about a relationship with Christ. It isn’t about religion. He isn’t exactly saying he hates religion. He is pointing out that we get so focused on doing right,being right & getting right before we come to Him. When it is the other way around. He accepts us as we are, all the time. Religion gets in the middle. I think his point is accurate. We have to wrap our hearts around that Christ has already done for us everthing he is going to do. Religion isn’t all bad. And, I don’t think he is hating on it either. He is pointing you directly to Christ’s finished work. Listen to the sermon & forget the title of it, because the title doesn’t reflect the message here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s